Existing User? Login here!


Back to Boards

Scoring question


Scoring question

Shouldn't all the runs scored in the 4th inning of the box score below be un-earned?

I can't understand the scoring here-am I missing something?

Re: Scoring question

Re: Re: Scoring question

Yes, and I've seen this before, PC getting mixed up because another player replaced the one who got on base by error, on fielders choice. So then it sees that player as getting on legitimately. But in real scoring, the first 2 guys are presumed out, then single, double (guy on first didnt score yet), and out ends the inning. No earned runs.

Re: Scoring question

That makes sense- thanks

Re: Re: Scoring question

Your link leads to an error. Do you recall which league or game? I’d like to look. A player coming off the bench should not impact scoring.

Re: Scoring question

https://www.pennantchase.com/lgBoxS..
That’s it. Not by bench, it was error then fielders choice groundout. Technically that’s 2 outs. Then 2 hits and a fly out would be 3rd out so any runs should be unearned.

Re: Re: Scoring question

This is great, thanks - it looks like the error out is getting wiped out on a FC, when it really shouldn't... I'll look into it...

Re: Scoring question

This could cost my 1-7 Pitcher the Cy Young award!!! NOT

Re: Re: Scoring question

I just released a fix to this, so if you see it again, let me know, but also let me know if you notice anything out of the ordinary.